Would the economy be better under John McCain?

Putz seems to think so:

THEY TOLD ME IF I VOTED FOR JOHN MCCAIN, we’d have a rerun of the Great Depression, with poverty-stricken Americans standing in line for hours in the cold for a chance at relief. And they were right!

I guess to buy this argument you have to believe even more tax cuts were required in January 2009, and I don't think many sane people do.